NCAA Division 1 All-American

Jason Nase  -  Point Pleasant Boro
1997:  8th Place - 134 pounds - Rider University

NCAA Division 2 All-American

Dan Transue  -  Point Pleasant Boro
1994:  6th Place - Heavyweight - Springfield College

NCAA Division 3 All-Americans

Pat Brady  -  Point Pleasant Boro
2004:  3rd Place - 141 pounds - The College of New Jersey

Ryan Budzek  -  Point Pleasant Boro
2019: National Champion - 149 pounds - The College of New Jersey