NCAA Division 1 All-American

Joe Hadge  -  Toms River East
1987:  6th Place - 142 pounds - Penn State University

NCAA Division 3 All-Americans

Michael Conklin  -  Toms River East
2022: 8th Place - 149 pounds - The College of New Jersey
2024: 7th Place - 149 pounds - The College of New Jersey
 

Ken Hoff  -  Toms River East
1990:  8th Place - 134 pounds - Montclair State University

Vinny Pedalino  -  Toms River East
2000:  5th Place - 125 pounds - McDaniel College
2001:  7th Place - 125 pounds - McDaniel College