NCAA Division 1 All-Americans

BJ Clagon  -  Toms River South
2015:  5th Place - 149 pounds - Rider University

Ken Theobold  -  Manchester / Toms River South
2017:  7th Place - 149 pounds - Rutgers University

NCAA Division 3 All-Americans

Kyle Bilquist  -  Toms River South
2008:  5th Place - Heavyweight - Delaware Valley College
2009:  4th Place - Heavyweight  -  Delaware Valley College
2010:  4th Place - Heavyweight  -  Delaware Valley College

Owen McClave  -  Toms River South
2018:  7th Place - 133 pounds - Coast Guard Academy

Brandon Murray  -  Toms River South
2019: 4th Place - 157 pounds - Loras College
2020: 157 pounds - Loras College